MALTA: Malta wins first round against EC court challenge to citizenship by investment scheme

The European Commission (EC) has no right to impose restrictions on EU Member States’ citizenship-by-investment (CBI) policies, according to an Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European Union set out in a statement on 4 October.

The CJEU will now examine the advocate’s recommendation that each Member State has unfettered rights to determine who is entitled to be one of their nationals.

An extract of the Advocate General’s Opinion in Case C-181/23 | Commission v Malta (Citizenship by investment) is set out below:

AG COLLINS: “The Commission has failed to prove that EU rules on citizenship (Article 20 TFEU) require that a ‘genuine link’ or ‘prior genuine link’ between a Member State and an individual must exist in order for it to grant citizenship.

“Following an amendment to the Maltese Citizenship Act in July 2020, the Republic of Malta adopted subsidiary legislation 1 which included the ‘Maltese Citizenship by Naturalisation for Exceptional Services by Direct Investment scheme’ 2 (the ‘2020 citizenship scheme’). Under the 2020 scheme, foreign investors could apply to be naturalised upon fulfilling a number of conditions, principally of a financial nature.

“In this infringement action, the Commission seeks a declaration that, by establishing and operating the 2020 citizenship scheme that offers naturalisation, in exchange for pre-determined payments or investments, to persons, notwithstanding the absence of a genuine link between them and the Republic of Malta,

“Malta failed to fulfil its obligations under Article 20 TFEU concerning EU citizenship 3 and the principle of sincere cooperation. In today’s opinion, Advocate General Anthony Collins advises the Court that the Commission has failed to prove that, in order to lawfully grant citizenship, EU law requires the existence of any ‘genuine’ or ‘prior genuine’ link between a Member State and an individual other than that required under a Member State’s domestic law.

“Advocate General Collins observes that, in these proceedings, the Commission must prove that a Member State has not fulfilled an obligation binding upon it at EU law and it may not rely upon any presumption in order to do so.”

7 February 2024

MALAYSIA: Former Malaysian finance minister charged following Pandora Papers revelations

Daim Zainuddin is among several high-profile Malaysians whose offshore wealth has come under scrutiny by Malaysia’s anti-corruption agency. Malaysian authorities have charged former finance minister

Read More
18 October 2024

EUROPE: Italian Government Raises Crypto Tax Amid EU Regulatory Changes

Italy plans to raise its capital gains tax on bitcoin to 42% amid growing adoption and as the EU prepares to implement its unified cryptocurrency regulations. Italy is set to increase its capital gains

Read More
14 November 2024

US: Trump win puts global corporate tax deal ‘in peril’

Attempts to stop some of the world’s biggest companies shifting profits across borders to avoid paying tax are “in peril” following Donald Trump’s definitive win in the US presidential election,

Read More
6 March 2024

CHINA: Chinese Investors Rush Abroad, Hitting Outbound Investment Limit

Chinese money is pouring into funds invested in offshore assets at breakneck speed, butting up against outbound investment limits and complicating Beijing’s efforts to revive domestic markets

Read More